No contracting out of human rights, High Court finds

Case: LW, KT, MC & Faulder v Sodexo Limited & Secretary of State for Justice

The High Court today has handed down a pivotal judgment on the human rights obligations that the State owes to prisoners serving their sentence in a private prison.

In HMP Peterborough, run by Sodexo Ltd, the four claimants (three female and one transgender prisoner) were unlawfully strip-searched.  Sodexo conceded that the strip-searches were unlawful and admitted to there being systemic failings at the prison.  The issue remained however, as to whether the Secretary of State for Justice had failed to put adequate and effective safeguards in place to protect the Claimants against a violation of Article 3 and 8 ECHR.

The High Court accepted the Claimants arguments that Article 8 had been breached, finding not only that the failings were serious, systemic and widespread, but that the legal framework relied on by the Secretary of State that governed their relationship with Sodexo was inadequate.  The High Court also found that it was not enough for Secretary of State to rely on the identification of the problem following the breaches, particularly given the vulnerability of the prisoners and the intrusive nature of strip-searches.

This decision will have significant implications for private government contracts beyond the realms of criminal justice.

Sophie Walker was instructed by Samuel Genen of Steel and Shamash Solicitors, acting for the claimants.

https://www.bailii. org/ew/cases/EWHC/Admin/2019/ 367.html

Related Barristers: Sophie Walker

Updates

Latest News

Our latest cases, upcoming events and news

cases
Court of Appeal confirms judicial discretion in CPN appeals
The Court of Appeal handed down its judgment in the joint appeals in Jen and Jamie Limited v SSHD and Johal v SSHD [2026] EWCA Civ 1446.
Brenda Efurhievwe
news
LexisNexis publishes a new Practical Guidance Note written in partnership with Katherine Soroya
Drawing on her expertise in the Immigration Tribunals, Katherine Soroya has authored a new Practical Guidance Note for LexisNexis, ‘An introduction to advocacy in the First-tier Tribunal’.
Katherine Soroya
news
Joseph Maggs's article “Upper Tribunal provides further guidance on standard of proof in asylum claims” published on Free Movement
​Joseph Maggs's new article on section 32 of the Nationality and Borders Act 2022 and the higher standard of proof in asylum claims has been published on Free Movement.
Joseph Maggs