Decision to refuse British nationality on the basis of illegal entry overturned

Victoria Laughton acted for a refugee who had been refused British citizenship on the basis that she was an illegal entrant and therefore of bad character.

Victoria challenged the refusal by way of judicial review on the basis that the policy was unlawful and/or had been applied unlawfully. After bringing a claim, the Home Office conceded the case and granted her citizenship.

Read coverage of the case via The Guardian: https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2025/dec/15/woman-who-fled-and-torture-in-drc-wins-uk-citizenship-case-after-home-office-u-turn 

Victoria was instructed by Jed Pennington of Wilson Solicitors.

Victoria is also instructed in the lead claims challenging the aspects of the Good Character policy relating to illegal entry/dangerous journeys (led by David Chirico KC). Permission has been granted, and the hearing is likely to be heard in June 2026.

Related Barristers: Victoria Laughton

Updates

Latest News

Our latest cases, upcoming events and news

news
Brenda Efurhievwe’s article “Judicial discretion and burden of proof in civil penalty appeals” published on Free Movement
The article considers two County Court decisions which demonstrate novel approaches regarding the issues of judicial discretion and the burden of proof in appeals against civil penalties.
Brenda Efurhievwe
cases
Olivia succeeds in judicial review challenging the Parole Board’s refusal of an oral hearing for IPP prisoner
Olivia succeeded in challenging the Parole Board’s refusal of an oral hearing on grounds of procedural unfairness and a breach of Article 5(4) ECHR.
Olivia Beach
publications
“Judicial discretion and burden of proof in civil penalty appeals – a light at the end of the tunnel?”
The article considers two County Court decisions which demonstrate novel approaches regarding the issues of judicial discretion and the burden of proof in appeals against civil penalties.
Brenda Efurhievwe