The Court of Appeal handed down its judgment in the joint appeals in Jen and Jamie Limited v SSHD and Johal v SSHD [2026] EWCA Civ 1446. The decision confirms that judges in Civil Penalty Notice (“CPN”) appeals have the discretion to consider matters outside of the SSHD’s Code of Practice when assessing whether the amount of the penalty is “too high”.
Brenda Efurhievwe represented Jen and Jamie Limited in its initial appeal before the County Court and throughout the subsequent Court of Appeal proceedings. Relying on her experience in carriers’ liability cases, Brenda assisted the Appellant in presenting arguments regarding relevant authorities in this analogous civil penalty regime. The Appellant submitted that, in line with the Court of Appeal decisions in International Transport Roth and Loane Transport, the mirror wording of the “Illegal working” regime also provided for significant judicial discretion on appeal.
Lord Justice Dingemans accepted the relevance of the carriers’ liability authorities, applying them alongside the Supreme Court’s recent confirmation of the penal nature of the CPN regime. The Court of Appeal held that the court shall determine the appeal by having regard to both the Code of Practice and any other matters which it thinks relevant. The matters which a court may consider include factors such as means, totality, culpability and the proportionality of the penalty.
Dingemans LJ found that, while considering proportionality, a court will have regard to the penalties set out in the relevant Code of Practice alongside other relevant factors, to decide whether it is proportionate to the breach in question. The Court also confirmed that, if an Appellant wishes to rely on their limited means in a CPN appeal, they should produce relevant evidence, such as a business’ audited accounts for the last three years.
Jen and Jamie’s case was remitted to the County Court to determine whether the penalty imposed on it was too high.
Pursuant to the recent decision in Akbars Restaurant v SSHD [2026] UKSC 26, the Court of Appeal also considered the validity of the CPNs in both cases. Following a concession by the SSHD, the CPN in Mr Johal’s case was withdrawn.
Brenda was led by Emma Harris of Goldsmith Chambers in the Court of Appeal, both instructed by Adrian Green of Stachiw Bashir Green. They appeared alongside Zainul Jafferji and Sheraaz Hingora of Clarendon Park Chambers, for the Appellant in the linked appeal of Johal v SSHD.